The Pros and Cons of Employee Monitoring
You log in, ready to beat all your daily tasks. But this nagging question is at the back of your memory: Is Big Boss watching your every step?
Employee monitoring gets a bad rap for the employees. But is it the prison of productivity that everybody makes it out to be? Or could it be that secret weapon to help drive your output and make you shine?
Or, is all the benefits for employers with none of the downsides? But is that so?
Buckle up because we're about to dissect this mystery of the pros and cons of employee monitoring.
What is Employee Monitoring?
Employee monitoring means tracking employee activities using different means. For effective management and control over employees, employers require tracking of employees' internet usage, web surfing data, emails, computer activity, phone calls, GPS location, and even physical movement within the office.
As remote work has become popular over time, remote employee monitoring has become indispensable nowadays. These practices enhance efficiency and productivity in your company but, at the same time, raise concerns about employee privacy and ethical compliance.
Understanding the implications of employee monitoring can help you develop effective strategies for the betterment of your organization and your workforce.
Pros of Employee Monitoring
Increase overall organizational productivity
1. Focus on Work-Related Activities
By practicing employee monitoring within your workforce, you will be able to ensure that your employees remain engaged in work-related activities at your workplace or while they are on duty. It will help you to minimize non-work-related activities such as personal phone calls, browsing social media, etc.
With this, you will be able to identify your employees' level of engagement with the designated task. By keeping your employees more focused, you can enhance the obligations of your employees, and it, in turn, will increase your productivity
2. Performance Metrics
Employee monitoring allows you to gather precise data and gives you a clear insight into individual and team performance. You may set up some Key Performance Indicators (KPIs), such as task completion rates, response times, overall productivity levels, etc., and can determine the rate of compliance with them.
With this data, you can identify the top performers as well as the employees who require additional support, training, or motivation. If you regularly review those data, you can optimize the use of your workforce, set realistic goals, and maximize output from your operation.
3. Identifying Time Wasters
By monitoring employees' activity, you can identify the actions that waste time and increase non-work-related activity. By analyzing the data carefully, you may point out the activity that wastes time.
You can block distracting websites, restructure workflows, or provide additional training or counseling to individuals. By practicing this proactive approach, you can ensure that your employees spend time on productive and meaningful tasks.
Enhanced Security
1. Data Protection
Employee monitoring can help you enhance data security in your organization. Having a deep and clear overview of your employees' actions and activities allows you to control the flow of sensitive data and information easily.
If you experience or suspect data security threats, monitoring tools will help you with real-time alerts and activity logs. You will get clear insights on how data are being used and shared. It will enable you to take proper measures to safeguard your critical information.
2. Compliance
If you are an owner of a business, you must ensure compliance with industry regulations and labor law. As employee monitoring assists you with providing comprehensive records of activities, you can adjust your work plan and organization structure to achieve this.
You can provide necessary data during audits or investigations and prove that you adhere to and follow the laws and regulations. Employee monitoring tools can alert you about non-compliant activities in real time so that you can address them to prevent your company from facing penalties and avoid legal issues.
Improved Resource Allocation
1. Resource Utilization
If you practice employee monitoring, you will understand how your organization's resources are being utilized. By tracking the time spent on various tasks, you can easily identify where the resources are underutilized or misused.
Once you have a complete picture of your workforce, you will find ways to optimize workflows, govern works through simplification, and improve overall efficiency. It helps you to concentrate your manpower towards high-priority workloads.
2. Cost Savings
If you implement employee monitoring in your business, there are a lot of aspects in which you can get significant cost savings. It helps you identify the actual work done by your employee, and hence, you can eliminate non-work-related activity and time theft.
It also enables you to manage your staff according to the exact requirements of a specific branch. Thus, you will reduce inefficient staffing and save costs. Also, by careful monitoring of your company resource usage, you can optimize the requirement of office supplies and other commodities.
3. Project Management
Effective project management is key to a successful business. It is interconnected with the quality of your work and the trust of your client. To ensure the proper functioning of your employees in performing against deadlines and objectives, you must have some means of monitoring.
With this, you will get some clear insights about how your team is performing, where the employees are overburdened or underutilized, how the work plan can be optimized to avoid bottlenecks of the project, etc.
Enhanced Employee Development
1. Performance Measurement
Performance measurement in an organization helps you achieve better growth and motivate your employees to perform well. Effective evaluation parameter selection creates a competitive and cooperative work environment.
To measure your employees' performance, you need to monitor and track their activity. With a clear benchmarking of your employees' performance, you can easily determine the best team or individual to offer promotions, raises, and other rewards.
2. Skill Gaps
As an employer, identifying skill gaps can make you a strong competitor in the market. With technology advancing rapidly, a proper understanding and forecast of your teams' skill deficiencies are essential for survival.
By analyzing employee data, you can easily identify areas of strength and areas needing development. Skill gaps can also create project bottlenecks. It also assists you in making correct decisions about training arrangements to improve the skills and efficiency of your workforce.
3. Feedback Loop
If you want smooth and effective organizational growth and better management, you need to establish a feedback mechanism in your organization. An employee monitoring system automatically creates a feedback loop on its own between employee and employer.
If you regularly review your employee performance data and provide constructive feedback, your employees will understand their areas of strengths and areas of improvement.
Better Client Service
1. Quality Assurance
Employee monitoring can significantly control quality assurance. By implementing employee monitoring, you will be able to observe your employees' interactions with your clients and the standard of service they provide.
With the help of monitoring tools, you can review the communications, identify any deviation from standard protocol, and address them promptly. Those steps will help you provide the best service to your customers.
2. Response Time
Quick responses to customers are crucial for excellent client service. Employee monitoring can help you achieve this. You can easily identify how quickly your team is responding to clients' queries.
When a customer receives a response in a shorter period, they feel relieved and more reliant on that service. Faster responses improve customer satisfaction and demonstrate your commitment to reliable service.
3. Client Feedback
To meet clients' expectations, you need to incorporate client feedback collection in your organization. By analyzing clients' feedback and employee performance data together, you can gain valuable insight into how your team is performing in meeting clients' expectations.
Carefully analyzing the client's feedback allows you to easily crosscheck their performance and output through employee monitoring and making decisions. This information helps you identify the areas of improvement and strengths within your workforce.
Potential Cons of Employee Monitoring
Privacy Concerns
1. Invasion of Privacy
Monitoring your employees can raise privacy concerns among your workforce. When you monitor your employees' activities, they might feel that their personal space is insecure.
It may create discomfort among the employees. It would be best if you created a balance between monitoring your employee activity for productivity and maintaining employees' privacy.
2. Data Misuse
The data collected from employee monitoring can be misused if not handled properly and used in a way other than intended. If the data is mishandled, it can create severe ethical and legal issues. Misuse of data can also create mistrust and a toxic work environment.
To prevent this, you should create clear policies on how the data will be recorded and used. Also, you should declare the privacy policy of the data you are recording with your workforce.
Decreased Employee Morale
1. Micromanagement
Monitoring your employees may lead to micromanagement. If you scrutinize every action of your employees, it can be detrimental to your team's morale. They need to be more confident about taking initiative and creativity. They will be focused only on meeting the surveillance criteria other than performing.
Micromanagement will also lead to frustration and dissatisfaction. To address this issue, you should use monitoring tools as a means of support rather than control.
2. Low Trust Environment
Trust is the most important component of a productive and positive work environment. Without it, the workforce can struggle to collaborate effectively to achieve the best performance. If you implement extensive employee monitoring, it can create a low-trust environment.
To manage this, you should emphasize that management is there to support the employees through monitoring, not to control or punish. Thus, you can achieve a positive work environment with a better and more committed workforce.
3. Increased Stress and Anxiety
When employees know that their every move is under surveillance, they experience increased stress and anxiety. Monitoring every action or activity may create pressure on them to work perfectly at all times, which is stressful and unrealistic.
This stress may lead to burnout and decreased productivity. When employees are constantly monitored, they are always concerned about avoiding mistakes rather than about reaching excellence.
Legal Issues
1. Non-compliance with regulations
If you cannot manage and control your employee monitoring tools and practices properly, legal problems may arise. Various laws and regulations need to be followed when designing your employee monitoring system.
Some examples of such laws and regulations are the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) in Europe and the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) in the United States, etc. Non-compliance with the regulations can result in fines and legal repercussions.
2. Employee Rights
If you cannot maintain transparency and adhere to regulations properly, it might infringe on your employees' rights. Employees have the right to know how their activity is being recorded and used.
Before monitoring, you must ensure that consent is obtained from the employees and that you respect their rights to privacy as protected by laws and regulations.
3. Potential for Discrimination
Improper use of employee monitoring data can lead to discrimination issues. If the data you collect through employee monitoring are being used to target certain employees to penalize or punish them, then discrimination claims might arise.
Is it Legal to Monitor Employee Activities?
The legality of employee monitoring depends on jurisdiction, the type of monitoring, and transparency in monitoring practices. But many countries allow to monitoring of employees under some regulations.
For example, in the U.S. employee monitoring is regulated by the federal and state laws of the land. Generally, it is acceptable to monitor an employee when on company equipment or during working hours, but the employer is held liable for a host of other regulations.
Implementing Employee Monitoring Software
Employee monitoring and time tracking tools like Apploye can mitigate the challenges and bring the best outcome. Companies especially tend to use the hybrid work model and remote work, where employee monitoring software is a prerequisite to running the employees.
However, before introducing any time tracking tool into your system, you must ensure some tasks for a successful result.
- Define potential reasons for employee monitoring and convey them to your subordinates.
- Make it clear and transparent about what and why you want to track employee activities.
- Enlist the features you want to apply (e.g., time tracking, activity logging, keystroke monitoring, email surveillance, video surveillance).
- Choose your preferred time-tracking tool. In that case, Apploye offers exclusive employee monitoring features that are perfect for remote and hybrid workforces.
- Ensure your tool complies with the local and international regulations.
- Implement strong data encryption and security measures. Also, access to monitoring data should be restricted to authorized personnel only.
- Gather feedback from employees to understand the impact of Apploye on their work and morale.
- Continuously seek ways to improve the monitoring process to enhance productivity, security, and employee satisfaction.
Conclusion
Employee monitoring offers increased productivity, enhanced security, compliance assurance, improved resource allocation, and better client service. Additionally, it helps maintain your employees' focus, track their performance, and identify inefficiencies.
However, it also risks data misuse and mishandling and raises privacy concerns. These issues may result in employee pushback, lack of trust, and increased stress among the workforce.
Related Article: